1. Loop Quiet 2 (best overall / best reusable)

Type: Reusable flanged silicone
Noise reduction: SNR 24 dB (approx. NRR 14)
Reusable: Yes, washable
In the box: 1 pair + 4 tip sizes (XS/S/M/L) + carry case
Check Deal

Loop built the Quiet 2 specifically for sleep, and it shows. There’s no rigid stem sticking out of your ear, just a soft, flexible silicone body and a round flange that seals the canal, so you can lie on your side and feel almost nothing against the pillow.

The clever part is the four included ear-tip sizes. Most earplugs are one-size-fits-most and leak on anyone with smaller or larger canals; here you swap tips until you get a proper seal, which is what actually determines how much noise you block. They’re washable and rated to last years, so the higher upfront price works out cheaper than bags of disposable foam.

At around 24 dB they take the sharp edge off snoring, traffic and chatter without the sealed-in, pressurised feeling that puts people off foam. If your partner is a truly thunderous snorer, step up to foam; for everyone else this is the one to buy first.

Pick if...

You want the most comfortable all-night option that’s still reusable, and you sleep on your side.

Check Current Price

Pros

  • Soft, stemless silicone: nothing hard to press against the pillow for side sleepers
  • Four tip sizes included: dial in a proper seal whatever your ear size
  • Washable and reusable: lasts years, so cheaper over time than disposable foam
  • Low-profile fit: sits flush with the ear, comfortable under a pillow

Cons

  • Moderate blocking: about 24 dB, so very heavy snoring may still get through
  • Fit is size-dependent: pick the wrong tip and the seal (and the noise blocking) suffers
  • Pricier upfront: costs more than a bag of foam plugs to start
SpecDetail
TypeReusable flexible silicone, flanged
Noise reductionSNR 24 dB (approx. NRR 14)
Sizes4 interchangeable tips (XS, S, M, L)
ReusableYes, washable, brand-rated multi-year
PriceCheck current price on Amazon

Specs per Loop’s published product details. Amazon pricing changes often — check the current price on the product page. Verified July 2026.

2. Mack’s Ultra Soft Foam (best for blocking the most noise)

Mack’s Ultra Soft Foam earplugs

Type: Disposable PU/PVC foam
Noise reduction: NRR 32 (top of the US scale)
Reusable: A few uses per pair
Pack: Multi-pair bottle
Check Deal

When you need to block the maximum amount of noise, foam still wins, and Mack’s Ultra Soft are among the highest-rated foam plugs you can buy at NRR 32. Roll them down, insert and let them expand to fill the canal, and a snoring partner or a busy street drops to a murmur.

The trade-off is the one every foam plug makes: they sit inside the canal and expand, which some side sleepers find uncomfortable, and the plugged, pressurised feeling isn’t for everyone. They’re also semi-disposable, good for a handful of nights each before hygiene says bin them, so you buy them in bulk.

For the price of a coffee you get a big bottle of pairs, making these the go-to for the worst noise nights and for anyone who just wants cheap, maximum blocking.

Pick if...

You want the strongest noise blocking on this list and don’t mind foam in the ear canal.

Check Current Price

Pros

  • Highest blocking here: NRR 32 is about as much as any foam plug offers
  • Very cheap per pair: sold in bulk bottles, so replacing them is painless
  • Soft, slow-expanding foam: comfortable to seat and easier on the canal than stiff foam
  • Huge trusted track record: one of the most-reviewed sleep earplugs in the world

Cons

  • Sits inside the canal: the expanding fit can bother dedicated side sleepers
  • Semi-disposable: hygiene limits each pair to a few nights
  • Can feel over-plugged: the sealed-in sensation is not for everyone
SpecDetail
TypeDisposable soft foam (roll-down)
Noise reductionNRR 32
ReusableA few uses per pair
PackMulti-pair bottle
PriceCheck current price on Amazon

Specs per Mack’s published product details. Amazon pricing changes often — check the current price on the product page. Verified July 2026.

3. Mack’s Pillow Soft Silicone Putty (best for side sleepers)

Type: Moldable silicone putty (caps the ear)
Noise reduction: NRR 22
Reusable: Single-use-ish
Pack: 12 pairs
Check Deal

If you can’t stand anything pushed into your ear canal, moldable putty is the answer, and Mack’s Pillow Soft is the classic. You warm a ball of soft silicone between your fingers and press it over the opening of the ear, so it caps the canal rather than plugging it. Nothing goes inside and nothing sticks out to press on the pillow.

That makes it one of the most comfortable options for side and stomach sleepers, and the seal is excellent for snoring and for keeping water out. It’s the same putty generations of Australians have bought at the chemist for swimming and sleeping.

At NRR 22 the blocking is moderate rather than maximal, the putty is basically single-use and can stick to long hair, and it softens in hot weather. But for pillow comfort, nothing here beats it.

Pick if...

You hate anything inside your ear canal and want a comfortable seal for sleeping on your side.

Check Current Price

Pros

  • Caps the ear, doesn’t insert: nothing in the canal and nothing to press on the pillow
  • Excellent comfort for side sleepers: the most pillow-friendly option on this list
  • Great water and snore seal: moulds tightly over the ear opening
  • Trusted chemist staple: a proven design sold for decades

Cons

  • Moderate blocking: NRR 22 is lower than foam for very loud noise
  • Basically single-use: the putty picks up grit and can stick to long hair
  • Softens in heat: gets messy to mould on hot nights
SpecDetail
TypeMoldable silicone putty (caps canal)
Noise reductionNRR 22
ReusableSingle-use-ish
Pack12 pairs
PriceCheck current price on Amazon

Specs per Mack’s published product details. Amazon pricing changes often — check the current price on the product page. Verified July 2026.

4. Earjobs Silicone Putty (best value)

Earjobs silicone putty earplugs

Type: Moldable silicone putty
Noise reduction: Moderate
Reusable: Single-use-ish
Pack: Multi-pair
Check Deal

Earjobs is an Australian-run brand selling the same putty-cap concept as Mack’s Pillow Soft, usually at a keener price and in generous multi-pair packs. You get the same over-the-ear comfort that suits side sleepers, without inserting anything into the canal.

It’s the value pick: if you like putty and go through it quickly, buying Earjobs in bulk keeps the cost per night down. The attenuation is moderate, the putty is fiddlier to mould in cold weather, and like all putty it’s essentially single-use, but for the money it’s hard to fault.

Pick if...

You like moldable putty and want the lowest cost per pair from an Australian brand.

Check Current Price

Pros

  • Same putty-cap comfort: over-the-ear fit that side sleepers like, no canal insertion
  • Keen pricing: usually cheaper per pair than the big-name putty
  • Australian brand: local support and fast domestic shipping
  • Generous multi-packs: good value if you get through putty quickly

Cons

  • Moderate attenuation: not for blocking the very loudest noise
  • Single-use-ish: picks up grit and hair like all putty
  • Fiddly in the cold: the putty is stiffer to mould on cold nights
SpecDetail
TypeMoldable silicone putty (caps canal)
Noise reductionModerate
ReusableSingle-use-ish
PackMulti-pair
PriceCheck current price on Amazon

Specs per Earjobs’ published product details. Amazon pricing changes often — check the current price on the product page. Verified July 2026.

5. Deep Sleeps Reusable Silicone (best cheap reusable)

Deep Sleeps reusable silicone earplugs

Type: Reusable flanged silicone
Noise reduction: Moderate
Reusable: Yes, washable
Pack: Multiple pairs + case
Check Deal

If you like the idea of the Loop but want to spend far less, Deep Sleeps reusable silicone plugs are the budget stand-in. They use soft, washable flanged silicone that seals the canal and can be rinsed and reused, and they typically ship with several pairs plus a carry case.

They don’t match the Loop’s refinement or its range of tip sizes, so getting a perfect seal is more hit-and-miss, and the attenuation is moderate. But as a cheap, reusable everyday option they’re a sensible pick, and having spares means you always have a clean set to hand.

Pick if...

You want reusable silicone plugs at a rock-bottom price and don’t need premium tip sizing.

Check Current Price

Pros

  • Reusable and washable: rinse and reuse rather than binning after a few nights
  • Cheap: a fraction of the price of premium reusable plugs
  • Multiple pairs included: always a clean spare set on hand
  • Soft flanged silicone: low-profile and reasonably side-sleeper friendly

Cons

  • Fewer sizing options: harder to get a perfect seal than the Loop Quiet 2
  • Moderate blocking: won’t match foam for the loudest noise
  • Less refined: build quality is basic for the low price
SpecDetail
TypeReusable flanged silicone
Noise reductionModerate
ReusableYes, washable
PackMultiple pairs + case
PriceCheck current price on Amazon

Specs per Deep Sleeps’ published product details. Amazon pricing changes often — check the current price on the product page. Verified July 2026.

How we choose earplugs for sleeping

There’s no lab-coat theatre here, just a consistent way of weighing what actually matters when you’re trying to sleep through noise. For every earplug on this page we:

  • Prioritised all-night comfort: a plug that blocks noise but hurts when you roll onto your side is useless, so low-profile and stemless designs score highest for sleep.
  • Checked the noise reduction rating: NRR (US) and SNR (EU) tell you how much sound each plug blocks, and we matched the rating to the job rather than assuming higher is always better.
  • Weighed fit and sizing: the seal is what determines real-world blocking, so we favoured plugs with multiple sizes or a moldable fit that suits more ears.
  • Balanced cost and reuse: reusable silicone costs more upfront but less over time; disposable foam and putty are cheap but ongoing. We flagged which suits which buyer.
  • Read verified owner reviews: we aggregated ratings across Amazon Australia and pharmacy retailers and re-checked them at this update.

Sleep Society may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. That never changes the order of our picks; the Loop Quiet 2 tops this list on comfort and versatility, not on what it pays.